Why GM grain production won't fly in South Australia. (Part 1)

I’m not pro-GM.  I’m not anti-GM.

I’m pro South Australia’s food industry.

This means finding a business model that allows our food system to access markets profitably.

To achieve that outcome there will be compromises.  There always is when achieving a consensus on strategy.  The alternative strategy is we do nothing.

I think we all agree, we don’t want the compromise of that.

The current discussion about growing GM grain in South Australia is far from centred.

People are debating issues that have little relevance to the actual outcome they seek.

Alarmist headlines are not helping.

Let’s be clear.  There is currently a moratorium in GM grain.  Not a ban.

My observation is that advocates have failed in their bid to halt a suspension on the introduction of GM grain production in South Australia, not because of what they have said, but because of what they haven’t said.  Or rather, the key question they haven’t answered.

That is, how will the introduction of GM grain into South Australia’s highly differentiated food system, add value to processors and consumers here and abroad?

The South Australian Government has adopted an integrated perspective of South Australia’s food industry.  For example, understanding the relationship between food and tourism is why an integrated approach is important for South Australia.

Hence we have Tourism Ministers making announcements about our food system – a smart marketing move.

Individual debates such as those concerning GM grain will always circulate.  But the ground-swell of opinion across South Australia’s broader food industry is that we need to dare-to-be-different and use this to build an individual sense-of-place about South Australian food that can be marketed to the rest of the world.

The South Australian food industry has adopted the mantra to provide premium food produced to the highest standards and to give processors and consumers of our food system an authentic food experience.

Consequently, the South Australian Government has developed, prioritised and committed itself to a range of programs and market-centric strategies propelling South Australia’s food industry and its participants around the globe, capturing a niche in consumer sentiment.

This is achieved because contrary to popular opinion, whether or not GM grain is safe is not the issue.  It is the current view of processors and consumers that GM grain is not premium quality or an authentic food experience – safe or otherwise.

For the moment it means some individual farm-gate requests have not been met in order to achieve the greater-good for South Australia’s food industry.

Over the next 5 years, it is vital the local grain production community soundly demonstrates how their wishes to grow GM grain can be integrated into the greater vision for South Australia’s food industry already underway.

The moratorium is an important period allowing grain producers to now view themselves as part of the broader food value chain community in South Australia or risk being isolated from future decisions.

Part 2 asks if the introduction of GM grain into South Australia’s highly differentiated food system will add value to processors and consumers here and abroad; and why the discussion should not be centred on the issue of safety.

What is the value in eating GM grains?  This is a key issue.

Unless the question of value can be answered for food consumers the proposition we will grow GM grain in South Australia is unlikely from a food marketing perspective.